For some reason my personal proposal happens contrary to the very first and you will simple place out of relationship, however, even when our company is in support of marriage, as well as suitable of males just who build legislation for all of us, we should silently believe mans real disease. Taking into account one laws derives of facts, this type of boys have joined here to type a constitution and that wipes brush the latest errors of the past and you will seeks a special highway for future years, [thus] it is necessary which they judiciously investigation the brand new standards of your landscaping and you will come to the conclusion there are anything during the our life plus in our world that we simply http://datingmentor.org/single-men-dating-san-jose-california/ cannot in the any way close all of our eyes, that people have to deal with valiantly. 51

Of the asserting one a great disjuncture existed anywhere between legislators’ ideals and you can “societal truth,” Hernandez argued one she is actually attacking for Cubans who were perhaps not aren’t considered to be different types of sexual propriety and you may, therefore, was indeed unjustly disenfranchised

I’ve arrived at the latest Construction to moderately safeguard, on good my personal ability, the newest Cuban lady, the hitched woman, the brand new unmarried lady, brand new white woman, the fresh black colored woman, women of all the kinds. I have to point out that there are a great number of Cuban women in tough and humiliating things, who will be as the respectable so when deserving of merit as is actually most other people, that simply due to the fact the woman is for the a totally free union, does not mean that people should think about her along with her family unit members depraved. 52

Hernandez reasoned you to definitely simple court sanction away from a sexual union you can expect to never be the actual only real proof that any particular one is an actual and ethical resident

Twenty-a couple of out of the sixty-half a dozen System people probably the example chosen so you’re able to agree Hernandez’s proposition. The majority of people who voted in like reasoned which perform assist males when you look at the consensual unions to get to know an identical duties and you may requirements that married men have been bound to fulfill and you will, ergo, do cover all women and children. Such as, modern Set up representative Capablanca debated you to “though it [Hernandez’s amendment] appears paradoxical, far from becoming…a strike on the wedding, it really is a security of it.” 53 The guy informed me, “Whenever people remember that they are accountable for people which have which he’s got a consensual relationship and also for the pupils one impact from these free unions, then they doesn’t practice consensual unions but in matrimony.” 54 Capablanca represented men since the almost naturally irresponsible, and you can suggested that women called for State protection from him or her. Someone else echoed their rationale.

However, more System professionals, progressives and you will traditionals, balked on Hernandez’s suggestion, arguing that it was maybe not conducive to help you popular improvements and do offer liberties and you may privileges so you can undeserving, depraved people. Conventional Assembly associate Cortina added a beneficial competing fight against Hernandez’s proposal, framing their dissent due to the fact a battle having modernity, progress, and society. He said that a beneficial constitutional be certain that to adopt consensual unions comparable to judge marriages do basically send Cuba regarding on a legal road divergent from compared to “the gentle regions on earth” and you will “wreck…brand new matrimonial program, and also make [it] entirely inadequate.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “Whether it amendment was in fact accepted, we possibly may write a huge distress when you look at the legal marriage, and we also would grab the consequences of one’s political wave and therefore i’ve merely existed as a consequence of, to help you sectors of one’s psychological and you may family lifestyle, [sectors] and that don’t have to end up being transformed on major and you will perturbing way that was suggested.” 56 For Cortina, new 1933 wave try a governmental wave, and next reform is always to simply connect with politics: Personal facts should be kept alone.